Riley Gaines is a Literal Piece of Shit
The Grotesque Lie Linking Trans Identity to Pedophilia
In the festering swamp of American political discourse, a particularly vile narrative has emerged—one so fucking absurd, so patently devoid of scientific merit, that its mere existence would be laughable if it weren't so goddamn dangerous. I'm talking about the nauseating claim, uttered with straight-faced conviction by the likes of Riley Gaines on Charlie Kirk's show, that transgender identity is somehow—somehow—a gateway to normalizing pedophilia.
Let that sink into your brain for a moment. Breathe in the putrid stench of this logic. Feel the visceral wrongness of it coat your synapses like toxic sludge.
The Raw Sewage of Fearmongering
Gaines states with disturbing confidence: "I believe the gender ideology movement as a whole really is an attempt to normalize pedophilia, across the board." This isn't just wrong. It's not merely incorrect. It's a deliberate, calculated fabrication designed to create moral panic—a time-tested method that bigots have deployed against vulnerable minorities throughout history.
When Donny McFartsalot and his MAGA minions need to whip up hatred, they follow a predictable playbook: find a marginalized group, connect them to something universally reviled (like harming children), and watch as the torches and pitchforks come out. It's cynical. It's cruel. And when you examine it under the harsh light of actual fucking evidence, it crumbles like a sandcastle in a hurricane.
What the Science Actually Says
The American Psychological Association (APA), the largest association of psychologists in the United States, has officially adopted a resolution opposing efforts to change people's gender identity, citing scientific research showing that such actions may be harmful. The APA explicitly states that attempts to frame gender-affirming care as harmful to youth are based on "misleading and unfounded narratives that mischaracterize gender dysphoria and affirming care." This isn't fringe opinion—it's the consensus position of the foremost psychological authority in the country.
Medical organizations ranging from the American Medical Association to the American Academy of Pediatrics have released statements supporting gender-affirming care and debunking the harmful myths surrounding transgender individuals. These statements aren't casual observations—they're carefully crafted positions based on rigorous peer-reviewed research.
The claim that transgender identity leads to pedophilia isn't just unsupported by evidence—it's actively contradicted by it. There is zero—I repeat, zero—credible scientific evidence linking gender identity to pedophilia. None. Not a fucking shred.
The Mythical "Rapid Onset"
One of the cornerstones of anti-transgender rhetoric is the concept of "rapid-onset gender dysphoria" (ROGD)—the idea that young people, particularly adolescent girls, are suddenly identifying as transgender due to social contagion. This concept was introduced in a deeply flawed 2018 study that surveyed not transgender youth themselves, but their parents—parents specifically recruited from websites known to be critical of transgender acceptance.
A 2021 study published in the Journal of Pediatrics examined this claim and found no evidence supporting the ROGD hypothesis. The researchers found that 98.3% of transgender youth seeking gender-affirming care had realized more than a year prior that they might be transgender—hardly a "rapid onset."
The ROGD concept has been rejected by over 60 major medical organizations, including the American Psychological Association and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), which called for its elimination from clinical settings due to the concept's lack of scientific validity and its potential to stigmatize transgender youth.
The Vile History of Stigmatization
There's a dark, bloodied thread that runs through history: the tendency to portray minority groups as threats to children. In the mid-20th century, gay men were routinely portrayed as pedophiles in public service announcements. Black men were lynched based on fabricated accusations of assaulting white women and children. Jewish people were depicted as child-killers in medieval blood libel accusations.
The rhetoric against transgender people follows this exact same pattern, and it's just as baseless, just as cruel, and just as fucking intentional. It's not about protecting kids. It's never been about protecting kids. It's about creating a moral panic that can be weaponized against a vulnerable group.
You can smell the desperation in these tactics. As society has become increasingly accepting of gay and lesbian people, bigots have shifted their focus to transgender individuals—particularly transgender youth—as their new target. Same hatred, different victim.
The Real Threat to Children
Here's what actually harms children: telling them their identity is invalid. Denying them appropriate medical care. Creating an environment so hostile that they see no future for themselves.
Transgender youth face staggering rates of suicide attempts, with studies showing rates up to 40% compared to about 5% in the general population. Research consistently demonstrates that gender-affirming care and support significantly reduce these rates. A study published in the Journal of Adolescent Health found that transgender youth who were able to use their chosen names in multiple contexts experienced 71% fewer symptoms of severe depression and a 65% decrease in suicidal thoughts.
The American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Medical Association, and the American Psychiatric Association have all issued policy statements supporting gender-affirming care for transgender youth precisely because the evidence shows it saves lives.
The Rancid Core of the Argument
When you strip away the pseudo-scientific veneer and the faux concern for children, what you're left with is raw, unfiltered bigotry. It's the same rotten core that has powered every moral panic throughout history.
The argument relies on fear rather than facts, on disgust rather than data. It appeals to our most primitive instincts rather than our capacity for compassion and critical thinking. It's intellectually lazy, morally bankrupt, and ethically reprehensible.
And yet, it works. It fucking works. Because fear is a powerful motivator, and nothing triggers fear like the suggestion that children are in danger.
Breaking Down the Psychological Warfare
Let's dissect what's happening when Gaines and others make these claims:
They're creating a false equivalence between gender identity (a deeply personal aspect of who someone is) and pedophilia (a harmful paraphilia that victimizes children).
They're implying that acceptance of transgender people will lead to acceptance of child abuse—a classic slippery slope fallacy that ignores the crucial distinction between consensual adult identity and criminal behavior that harms others.
They're dismissing the lived experiences of millions of transgender individuals worldwide, reducing their complex identities to a sinister "ideology."
They're framing their own bigotry as concern for children, using kids as human shields for their prejudice.
This isn't just factually wrong—it's psychologically manipulative. It's designed to bypass rational thought and activate primal protective instincts. It's propaganda in its purest, most vile form.
The Bloody Consequences
Words have consequences. Rhetoric like this doesn't just float harmlessly in the ether—it seeps into legislation, into school policies, into healthcare decisions, and into the fists of those who commit hate crimes.
In recent years, we've seen a tsunami of anti-transgender bills across the United States, many explicitly targeting transgender youth. These bills don't exist in a vacuum—they're the direct result of the kind of fear-mongering that Gaines and others peddle.
When transgender people are portrayed as threats rather than as human beings deserving of dignity and respect, violence against them becomes easier to justify. Transgender individuals, particularly transgender women of color, face disproportionately high rates of violence and murder.
The blood spilled by this violence stains the hands of those who spread these lies.
What Science Really Tells Us About Gender
Gender identity is complex and multifaceted. It's influenced by biological, psychological, and social factors. The scientific consensus, based on decades of research, is that gender exists on a spectrum rather than as a rigid binary, and that transgender identities are valid expressions of human diversity.
Gender dysphoria—the distress that can arise from the mismatch between one's assigned gender at birth and one's gender identity—is recognized as a real condition by all major medical and psychological associations. It's not a delusion, not a trend, not a social contagion, and certainly not a fucking plot to normalize pedophilia.
The treatment for gender dysphoria, particularly in adolescents, is approached with care and nuance. Contrary to the hysterical claims of critics, no one is performing irreversible surgeries on young children. The standard of care involves social transition (changes in name, pronouns, and presentation), puberty blockers (which are reversible), and, in some cases for older adolescents, hormone therapy. Surgical interventions are generally not recommended until adulthood.
This approach is supported by research showing positive outcomes in terms of psychological well-being and quality of life.
The Breathtaking Hypocrisy
The most infuriating aspect of this whole disgusting narrative is the jaw-dropping hypocrisy of those who propagate it. The same people who claim to be protecting children from the "transgender agenda" often show remarkably little concern for children in other contexts.
They oppose comprehensive sex education that would actually help children identify and report abuse. They slash funding for social services that protect vulnerable children. They support policies that tear families apart and put children in cages.
Their concern for children is selective at best, and cynically performative at worst.
Opening the Loop: What This Means for You
If you've made it this far, you're probably wondering: Why should I care? What does this mean for me, for my community, for our collective future?
The targeting of transgender people isn't happening in isolation. It's part of a broader assault on bodily autonomy, on privacy, on the fundamental right to self-determination. Today it's transgender rights under attack; tomorrow it could be your rights, your freedoms, your dignity.
The same people who want to control what gender you can express want to control what books you can read, what history you can learn, what healthcare decisions you can make. The attack on transgender rights is the canary in the coal mine—a warning of the broader restrictions on freedom that await if we don't stand against this tide of authoritarian control.
But here's the thing: This fight isn't just about transgender rights. It's about the kind of society we want to build. Do we want a world where diversity is celebrated, where individuals are free to be their authentic selves? Or do we want a world where conformity is enforced, where difference is demonized, where the powerful dictate the lives of the vulnerable?
The choice is ours. But to make that choice, we need to see through the fog of disinformation and recognize the cynical tactics being used to manipulate us. We need to reject the politics of fear and embrace the politics of compassion, of evidence, of human dignity.
Because at the end of the day, that's what this is really about: the dignity of every human being to live authentically, without fear, without shame, without the crushing weight of others' prejudice.
The trans community isn't asking for special treatment—they're asking for the freedom we all deserve. And their fight is our fight, whether we realize it or not.
This article is part of our premium subscription. For access to our complete system for understanding the intentional disinformation campaigns targeting marginalized communities, subscribe now.
Citations:
American Psychological Association. (2021). Resolution on gender identity change efforts. https://www.apa.org/about/policy/resolution-gender-identity-change-efforts.pdf
Bauer, G. R., et al. (2021). Do clinical data from transgender adolescents support the phenomenon of "rapid onset gender dysphoria"? Journal of Pediatrics, 134(4), 861-866.
Media Matters. 2025. “OutKick host Riley Gaines: “I believe the gender ideology movement as a whole really is an attempt to normalize pedophilia””
They used to do that to us LG folk too.
Research assistance by: me. :)